Gender Equality and Team Performance

Gender Equality and Team Performance

Aristotle astutely observed that, “We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit.” Unfortunately, when it comes to diversity and gender equality in the workplace, too often the day-to-day habits in many organizations fall short of excellence. In the January 2017 HBR article To Address Gender Bias at Your Company, Start with Teams, Todd Warren and Michelle King point out that, like so many unsuccessful change initiatives, altering diversity and inclusion habits proves far harder than leaders initially anticipate. The authors argue that the key to addressing gender equality starts with team behavior. They describe three ideas for changing how work is done in order to address the social patterns that foster gender bias, reduce team effectiveness, and stifle careers.

The first is to focus on individual team norms to identify interactions that inadvertently promote bias. Many studies have shown that healthy team norms are the foundation of a high-performing team. Google’s Project Aristotle, a three year effort to uncover the drivers of team excellence at Google, identified team norms such as psychological safety and conversation equality as essential to team effectiveness. Second, teams need to employ feedback practices that create rich conversations about team member expectations vs. their actual experiences. In their April 2016 HBR article Vague Feedback is Holding Women Back, Shelley Correll and Carolyn Simad support that idea, emphasizing the critical role of feedback on performance. They cite the example of a program run at Microsoft called Step Up – a year long leadership development process for women, during which they were provided with clear and actionable feedback. The program has achieved excellent early success in moving participants into leadership roles. Third, leaders need to regularly and systematically examine their own assumptions and habits concerning diversity and inclusion. This requires mindfulness, discipline, and a willingness to lead the development of new habits.

Current Research on Gender Equality and Teams

In their paper The Role of Gender in Team Collaboration and Performance, Julia Bear of the Israel Institute of Technology, and Anita Woolley of Carnegie Mellon University, reviewed the academic literature covering the effects of gender diversity on team processes and performance. Bear and Woolley focused specifically on women in STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics) and the increasing importance of team collaboration in these fields. They note a significant gender gap in the STEM fields and ask the question: Does gender diversity matter for team processes and performance? Their research results strongly supported the proposition that team collaboration is improved by the presence of women in the group. Concerning team performance, Bear and Woolley conclude that the effects of gender diversity are more complex. Their findings imply that in order to accrue the benefits of improved team collaboration and performance, women should be represented in parity with men (team size) along with equal clarity of purpose and role.

Building Diverse, Highly-Effective Teams

The work of Warner and King, and Bear and Woolley, illustrates the importance of gender diversity and equality to team collaboration and performance, and identifies ideas to establish the team foundations and behaviors that can change the status quo. My research supports their conclusions, demonstrating that the catalyst for improving team collaboration and performance is constant feedback on team member experiences versus expectations across key relationships. Specifically, exceptional teams are in the habit of:

  1. Establishing clear team norms that ensure gender parity, conversation equality, and psychological safety.
  2. Regularly gathering feedback on team member experiences vs. their expectations – and pay particular attention to any signs of conscious or unconscious bias.
  3. Consistently closing gaps between team member experiences and expectations across key relationships – those between team mates, with the team leader, and across teams with shared goals.

Establishing those habits enable teams to take a leap forward in their efforts to end gender bias. Gender bias and a lack of equality on teams and in organizations is costly in terms of reduced effectiveness, productivity, and innovation. Addressing gender bias not only increases team effectiveness, but improves people’s well-being and happiness at work and beyond.

Bear, Julia & Woolley, Anita. (2011). The Role of Gender in Team Collaboration and Performance. Interdisciplinary Science Reviews. 36. doi:10.1179/030801811X13013181961473.

The One Habit blog is brought to you by Xmetryx – the leader in Team Relationship Management (TRM) software.

Strong, trusting relationships are the heart of great teams. Xmetryx Team Relationship Management software gives you the tools to build those strong, trusting relationships. With Xmetryx TRM you will improve your team’s performance and well-being.

Start making the world better for your team with Xmetryx.

One comment

  1. Yes, i am agree with you. Men and women are equal at this time. Women are working equally then men. women are not weaker than men. They can do anything by herself. But in some places like offices women face some issue, colleague are harassed them etc. SDGCC is working against to it. They want to provide gender equality to women in Haryana. If we want to take step against to this then it is necessary that we have to work as a team.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.